Just read through these and I have actually gone out on a limb after reading some australian reviews on tyres and got the Maxxis MZA-1's...
I did not get very many km's out of my set of potenzas at all and at what they were quoting i was going to lean towards the GYear F1's but then i read the review. I have to get my receipt but it was less than half the replacement cost of the Potenzas.
I went for 245/35/19 so a little bit wider.
It was at 20 000km when i swapped over and i am at 55 000kms now and looks great still. It has so much more mid corner grip than i use to get with the potenzas... If i got on it midway through a fast sweeping corner or roundabout they use to lose a bit or becoming loose. The Maxxis just pulls through and wet weather traction is literally 3 times better.
It was cheap enough to give it a go and see if the reviews were full of it but it ended up being a very good gamble.
Unless if i drove in another scirocco with goodyears or other brands to literally feel it's significantly better it's hard to argue against them.