Support VWWC

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 18

Thread: Found a Skoda weakness - tow ball load.

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Location
    Northern Tasmania
    Posts
    480

    Found a Skoda weakness - tow ball load.

    I've found a weakness of Skoda's. The tow ball load limits are quite low.

    Been looking at getting a caravan and on paper my car should be fine for a smaller van. Diesel, 1600kg load limit, but only 75kg ball limit. Even the Kodiak's limit is 80kg! A lot of European cars have a limit under 100kg. They just do caravan stability differently - rather than rely on the brute force of weight to achieve it, they rely on more finely balanced vans and stability hitches.

    You can forget about any Australian style vans. You're restricted to European ones, but even amongst those there aren't many that have a tare ball weight light enough for an Octavia (in Australia).
    2008 Skoda Octavia Elegance TDI 4x4 wagon
    Bluefin 132Kw/385Nm, Racechips Response Control, Haldex Performance controller, H&R anti roll bars, Koni FSD shocks, SuperPro control arms & ball joints, subframe & gearshift mods, Full Dynamat interior, Polk Audio sound, Columbus, Bluetooth, MDI, parking sensors, camera. BBS SR 18x8" w/ 225/40xR18. 3M Crystalline tint.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Location
    Pacific Paradise QLD
    Posts
    7,157
    Users Country Flag
    Quote Originally Posted by wfdTamar View Post
    I've found a weakness of Skoda's. The tow ball load limits are quite low.

    Been looking at getting a caravan and on paper my car should be fine for a smaller van. Diesel, 1600kg load limit, but only 75kg ball limit. Even the Kodiak's limit is 80kg! A lot of European cars have a limit under 100kg. They just do caravan stability differently - rather than rely on the brute force of weight to achieve it, they rely on more finely balanced vans and stability hitches.

    You can forget about any Australian style vans. You're restricted to European ones, but even amongst those there aren't many that have a tare ball weight light enough for an Octavia (in Australia).

    Nothing new almost all Euro cars are the same. Pays to check before buying
    2021 Kamiq LE 110 , Moon White, BV cameras F & B
    Mamba Ebike to replace Tiguan

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Jul 2014
    Location
    Adelaide, SA
    Posts
    390
    Users Country Flag
    I believe the Toureg ball weight is up around 200 kg

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Location
    Northern Tasmania
    Posts
    480
    Thread Starter
    I wasn't considering towing a caravan when I bought the car, but I had seen that it won numerous UK tow car of the year (in it's weight category) awards. So I presumed it would be ok and in the UK it would be, but not so easy here.

    I've been using this site to check various cars to caravans.

    Outfit Matching Car and Caravan


    Also found this site which has a link to a PDF with loads of cars stats in it (a little out of date though). Vehicle Towing Mass Guide (although it's wrong for my car).

    Helpful Hints & Tips - Ian Grant's Caravans
    Last edited by wfdTamar; 14-05-2018 at 09:26 AM.
    2008 Skoda Octavia Elegance TDI 4x4 wagon
    Bluefin 132Kw/385Nm, Racechips Response Control, Haldex Performance controller, H&R anti roll bars, Koni FSD shocks, SuperPro control arms & ball joints, subframe & gearshift mods, Full Dynamat interior, Polk Audio sound, Columbus, Bluetooth, MDI, parking sensors, camera. BBS SR 18x8" w/ 225/40xR18. 3M Crystalline tint.

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Location
    Pacific Paradise QLD
    Posts
    7,157
    Users Country Flag
    Quote Originally Posted by wfdTamar View Post
    I wasn't considering towing a caravan when I bought the car, but I had seen that it won numerous UK tow car of the year (in it's weight category) awards. So I presumed it would be ok and in the UK it would be, but not so easy here.

    I've been using this site to check various cars to caravans.

    Outfit Matching Car and Caravan


    Also found this site which has a link to a PDF with loads of cars stats in it (a little out of date though). Vehicle Towing Mass Guide (although it's wrong for my car).

    Helpful Hints & Tips - Ian Grant's Caravans
    Hints from a long term vanner

    The towball weight of a new van as listed by a dealer can be far from reality.

    EG a van listed with a towball weight of 100kg WILL BE AT THE TARE of the van That is empty and when loaded up can be up to twice that.

    I had a big van that the towball weight was listed as just over 200kg. In reality when we were travelling it varied from day today and was usually 290- 300kg Also it would pay you to join the "caravanersforum.com.au" for helpful suggestions (and Arguments) LOL .

    For you to tow a van you would need to look at Eurovans like Baileys, Yorks, Adria or nowadays Jurgens make lightweight ones fitted out here in Australia. Almost any Aus van when loaded will have a towball weight in excess of your vehicles capacity .

    Also to say it is a weakness is unfair as the vehicles are produced in Europe in great quantity where the towing regs are different and as that is the main market thats what they build for. The small size of the AUS market does not justify meeting our towing conditions which to a large extent are old school where weight is defined as strength and isnt necessarily so.
    Must be bad roads in Europe and we dont hear of their "lightweight" vans falling to pieces all over the place.

    If you want to go vanning in Aus you need either a van as above or a tug that can tow our behemoths
    Last edited by Hillbilly; 14-05-2018 at 10:09 AM.
    2021 Kamiq LE 110 , Moon White, BV cameras F & B
    Mamba Ebike to replace Tiguan

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Location
    Pacific Paradise QLD
    Posts
    7,157
    Users Country Flag
    Quote Originally Posted by wfdTamar View Post
    I've found a weakness of Skoda's. The tow ball load limits are quite low.

    Been looking at getting a caravan and on paper my car should be fine for a smaller van. Diesel, 1600kg load limit, but only 75kg ball limit. Even the Kodiak's limit is 80kg! A lot of European cars have a limit under 100kg. They just do caravan stability differently - rather than rely on the brute force of weight to achieve it, they rely on more finely balanced vans and stability hitches.

    You can forget about any Australian style vans. You're restricted to European ones, but even amongst those there aren't many that have a tare ball weight light enough for an Octavia (in Australia).
    Tare ball weight means nothing. No one goes away with an empty van and as I said it increases it markedly once you load the van up.

    Also a great majority of vans will have an incorrect Tareweight on the compliance plate as most just make a line of vans and plate them all the same. Jayco are one maker that weighs each van.

    There has actually been instances where the buyer has specified extras and the plate hasnt been altered and it was found that the actual Tare almost exceeded the vans legal loaded limit and hence not fit for purpose. True story.
    Last edited by Hillbilly; 14-05-2018 at 10:04 AM.
    2021 Kamiq LE 110 , Moon White, BV cameras F & B
    Mamba Ebike to replace Tiguan

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Location
    Northern Tasmania
    Posts
    480
    Thread Starter
    Yes, thanks, but you're telling me stuff I know already and yes, joined various forums, had arguments with various silly old duffers who couldn't logic their way out of paper bags, or even follow a discussion, or recognise what a simple question is (very frustrating). I find this is one of those areas people (usually men) love to talk at you, not with you.

    Huuuuge amount of misinterpretation of what van Tare ball weight and Max ball weight means, even from dealers (well, c'mon, they are selling caravans, so not geniuses). Tare ball weight actually does mean something, as your limited to vans that have one within your cars max ball load weight. As you say, once you load the van ACTUAL ball weight can vary, but the tare ball weight is the starting point. No point looking at vans whose tare ball weight exceeds your car's max ball limit.

    I have still yet to find out if that is a legal requirement (that van tare ball weight not exceed car ball weight limit). I don't think so.

    Even considered another car - Passat is 90kg, Volvo XC70 90. Problem is to get a much higher limit you're looking at vehicles that chew almost twice the fuel (before you even put a van on). Maybe once you're towing that disparity may not be so great. Mercedes ML320 if you want a really big van. Or yes Toureg. I was expecting my car to go from 5.5 litres per 100 to around 10. Maybe say, the Merc or Toureg would go from 9.6 to 15?

    BUT - biggest stumbling block is previous mentioned old duffers using the 'oh yer ball weight has ter be 10% of yer van weight rubbish'. Completely missing the point that this is a Euro car and Euro van, NOT a 4WD with an Australian van.

    Yes, been looking primarily at UK market Baileys (the Australian ones are usually made to nose heavy), Geist and the like. However, the encounters on forums with all these silly old fools has really put me off the idea of caravanning. I wasn't sure if being cooped up in crowded caravan parks with boozing, noisy bogans and their mutts yapping etc. was for me and that pretty much sealed it.

    It also seems the height of western privileged, baby boomer selfishness to lug around a portable house burning up fossil fuel and the ozone layer.
    2008 Skoda Octavia Elegance TDI 4x4 wagon
    Bluefin 132Kw/385Nm, Racechips Response Control, Haldex Performance controller, H&R anti roll bars, Koni FSD shocks, SuperPro control arms & ball joints, subframe & gearshift mods, Full Dynamat interior, Polk Audio sound, Columbus, Bluetooth, MDI, parking sensors, camera. BBS SR 18x8" w/ 225/40xR18. 3M Crystalline tint.

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Location
    Pacific Paradise QLD
    Posts
    7,157
    Users Country Flag
    The ball weight may not exceed whatever the car manufacturer states what it is. There is no legal limit other than that. You constantly refer to TARE BALL WEIGHT which is meaning less except as you say if its too high you cant buy it.

    No good either buying one with a ballweight 10kg less than your maximum because it will be well over when you load it up.
    Far better to ask what is the ballweight at ATM
    You do not have to mix with the other campers We spent 2 years vanning around the country and stuck to ourselves mostly. Didnt have any problems and in fact made friends with a couple in 2009 who we still visit each other .
    Yes fuel will go up Our Landcuiser did 10.5 on its own on the highway but averaged about 18 towing and on one bad day on the Stuart in a head wind was about 23L -100km
    If you are so worried about the enviroment etc pehaps you should buy a bike . LOL


    By the look of your mods in your sig you dont seem to be worrying too much
    2021 Kamiq LE 110 , Moon White, BV cameras F & B
    Mamba Ebike to replace Tiguan

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Location
    Northern Tasmania
    Posts
    480
    Thread Starter
    Exactly - if the van tare ball weight is too high, you can't (or shouldn't) buy it. That's the trouble - 75 kg car limit! Not too many vans that low. That's why it's a constant issue. Also tare ball weight anything up to the cars limit is fine - then it's a matter of correct loading. It is not inevitable that it will increase when loaded. If it does, its loaded incorrectly. This is easier with a Euro van, having their axle more toward the middle of the van (than ones built here). European vans work more on the cart principle than the wheelbarrow. If people in the UK with Octavia's only bought vans that were well under the max ball weight they would never tow a van at all.

    Why do you presume because I have bought 'performance' stuff I race around at 100mph? My current tanks consumption is 5.2 litres per 100km (with a ten year old car). On the contrary, I cosset my car as I want it to last and I do think about my impact on the environment.
    2008 Skoda Octavia Elegance TDI 4x4 wagon
    Bluefin 132Kw/385Nm, Racechips Response Control, Haldex Performance controller, H&R anti roll bars, Koni FSD shocks, SuperPro control arms & ball joints, subframe & gearshift mods, Full Dynamat interior, Polk Audio sound, Columbus, Bluetooth, MDI, parking sensors, camera. BBS SR 18x8" w/ 225/40xR18. 3M Crystalline tint.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Adelaide hills, SA
    Posts
    9,709
    Users Country Flag

    Maybe our caravans aren’t built to the world standard.

    Or should I say European standard.

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
| |