Hi, I know this could be one of those subjective threads as it's a little dependent on view points but I wanted the pick the collective brains here.

I'm after a GTI and have two options..1st is a second hand Mk 5, 2006, with sunroof that has 15 000 on the dial and is available for about $28 000.

My second is a brand new Carbon Steel, Mk VI GTI with sunroof and Dynaudio for $42 000.

So I'm wondering, which one would you get?

Thanks!